ORDO WEEK 3 FRIDAY EVENING SONG

 

00:00 Welcome, my lords, to Isengard. 

Brief Discussion of His Reluctance to talk about AI

It's too early in the development

Analogy to the early criticisms of the printing press.

Risks looking silly when viewed in the future

01:30 Obligatory Beverage Tasting - A Sparkling Water Taste Test

10:21 Soda Stream Product Placement (not an official sponsor)

11:01 Bubble ASMR

12:32 Too many bubbles

13:50 San Pellegrino in a plastic bottle is like Mass with bad music

Part 2: California Pilgrimage

14:53 California Pilgrimage

16:16 Do you want to schedule a group, staff, or business pilgrimage? Reach out to Charlie. 

17:18 Pilgrimage Route

24:20 Stays and Liturgies on the Pilgrimage (some are open to the public!)

40:56 Why go on this pilgrimage?

Presents his case for singing the Hours

Vatican II Decree on Liturgy

83. Christ Jesus, high priest of the new and eternal covenant, taking human nature, introduced into this earthly exile that hymn which is sung throughout all ages in the halls of heaven. He joins the entire community of mankind to Himself, associating it with His own singing of this canticle of divine praise

Part 3: Chant Bot or Not?

51:16 Why AI Bot Music is not real liturgy

52:07 What do you think? Are these chant channels real chant or bot made?

55:05 Brief intermission on the new canticle translations

PAUL IS A STRICT LITURGICAL INTERPRETED

HE ALSO ASSUMES THAT WHEN THE NEW BREVIARY COMES OUT

WE WILL INSTANTALY CHANGE TO IT LIKE WHEN THE MISSAL 

CAME OUT. I WOULD SUSPECT THAT THE CURRENT BREVIARIES WILL

CONTINUE TO BE USED IN PERSONAL RECITATION

1:01:23 Back to it: Bot or Not?

1:02:40 Everything that's wrong with this AI chant

1:13:37 Check out these bot channels

1:16:58 Watch Paul make AI Slop

1:24:02 AI voice replication is so problematic (the commodification of the human person)

1:25:24 What should we listen to then? Floriani, Neums and Tunes, Sing the Hours

I FOUND THE ABOVE 25 MINUTES AN EXCELLENT TUTORIAL ON HOW ALL THESE AI GENERATED "GREGORIAN " CHANNELS ARE PRODUCING SOMETHING THAT HAS ALMOST NONE OF THE CHARACTERISTICS OF GREGORIAN CHANT EXCEPT FOR A LATIN TEXT WHICH IS RENDERED IN VERY GOOD LATIN 

THESE CHANNELS ARE GETTING FAR MORE TRAFFIC THAN REAL GREGORIAN CHANT CHANNELS AND THEY ARE DECEIVING VIEWERS THAT THERE ARE REAL PEOPLE PRODUCING THEM AND PRAYING FOR THEM 

1:25:51 Another Channel: Bot or Not?

1:32:33 One way to check if it's AI

1:33:35 Another Channel: Bot or Not?

1:36:11 AI is incapable of praying real Catholic prayer

1:37:05 The Collect Prayer from Mass

1:38:12 AI is blinding us

1:39:13 Another Channel: Bot or Not?

1:44:35 Effects of Baptism. You can't baptize AI.

1:47:15 Can you bless AI?

1:49:25 Support real Catholic musicians

1:50:15 Scandal: The State of Music in the American Catholic Church

1:51:35 Non-Catholics and Catholic Music

1:53:57 Let's Sing Scripture: Entrance Antiphon

 1:57:29 Scandal 2: Hymn Factories Funding Controversial Agendas

 1:59:35 The Actual, Musical Prescription for the Mass (USCCB Citation)

Ask